- Home
- Search
- Lily Anne Welty-Tamai
- All Reviews
Lily Welty-Tamai
AD
Based on 48 Users
Professor Welty is an amazing lecturer, and I would recommend anyone to take her class. She is a lot of fun, sweet, and you definitely would not regret it. She's a very clear lecturer and seriously is concerned about every one of her students and their learning. In a class of 80-ish, she also remembered quite a few names, especially if you participate. I also had a great TA, Angel, so that also contributed to the experience. The workload isn't that bad - there are a couple readings that you should do each lecture (which I honestly only skimmed or even skipped), but everything you need is gone over in detail during class anyway so you can get by not really doing most in that field. I was rather on the lazier side, but I always looked forward going to lecture even if I didn't do the reading.
Psst...the reading is from books you CAN get from the store. It's definitely on the cheaper end, and if you don't want to get the books, she uploads the parts you need onto CCLE, and there are a few copies you can check from in the library.
There's paper that is divided into a rough draft, peer review, and final draft, and you can get a lot of guidance if you want. The midterm has an essay (which prompts are discussed during discussion section) plus a few key terms, and the final has a similar format. As long as you go to each lecture and take notes, you'll be fine. Be sure to discuss the significance of each term because it is rather emphasized. Generally it's rather easy if you go to lecture.
She never posts her slides online or uses a podcast, so do yourself a favor and attend lecture each time. You might have to take quite a bit of notes (but she tells you what you need/don't need for the most part), but I can guarantee you that you'll have a great time anyway. Best GE professor so far, and it was definitely worth it!
From what I've heard about other GE's, this is definitely one of the more work-intensive ones. According to the syllabus, students are expected to read 4 hours per lecture, which in my opinion, is a lot of reading in addition to weekly reflections, tem paper, and other small homework assignments. The professor was very nice, but she was not the greatest at lecturing. The TA's were ok at best, mostly because they didn't help much, even at office hours. There were a multitude of extra credit assignments and other random assignments to pad your grade. Participation during discussions is important as well. They did not post individual grades on myUCLA, but I assume that our quarterly reflection on the grade we deserve in the class is heavily considered in assigning grades. I would do this class only if you are super passionate about Asian American studies. I did learn a lot, but there was a lot of effort needed.
Lecture:
Professor Welty uses lecture slides as a foundation for her lectures, and she comments on the slides. Her slides are not posted online, so I would recommend attending lectures. She tells you when it is unnecessary to copy down the information, such as statistics and quotes. I thoroughly enjoyed the course and found the topics interesting and relatable. Sometimes, she would show videos to illustrate her point. There will be some lectures where she would show a film and have you answer some questions and turn it in at the end of class. In general, Professor Welty is very engaging, and I looked forward to going to her lectures.
Discussion:
The discussion is made up of a short presentation by students each week and a discussion about that week's readings. I had to write six one-page reading reflection journals, which were graded very easily. Attending discussions is crucial to your grade, and you should try to engage in the discussions to earn more points. One absence = 3% marked off your grade, two absences =9% marked off your grade, three absences = 27% marked off your grade, etc.
Grade:
This is an essay GE to get an A in as long as you put in a little bit of effort. There is a midterm and a final. They both include passage identifications, which ask you to identify the key term and you will need to write about what it is and why it is important. Then, you also need to write an essay to answer one out of a few prompts. You will need to relate these to specific examples from the readings or the films. The midterm and final are both pretty easy as long as you study a little bit. There is a 6-8 page essay, and you are allowed to write about anything related to Asian American studies. Part of your grade for that is based on turning in an outline and a working draft. Discussion makes up a large portion of your grade too - this includes attendance, participation, and a group presentation. Also, there are occasional worksheets to fill out based on videos that you need to watch for homework. There are readings assigned that you are supposed to finish before each lecture, but they are really only to aid your understanding of the topic. The readings assigned are very long and sometimes boring, but Professor Welty will teach you that you only need to read the introduction, conclusion, and the first sentence of each body paragraph. You will need to buy a textbook called Contemporary Asian America, The New Chinese America, and The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. There are several opportunities to earn extra credit, such as going to a museum or attending a guest lecture. At the end of the quarter, you turn in a self-reflection to suggest what grade you think you deserve, and the TA takes it into consideration before assigning you a grade.
Grade Breakdown:
Midterm: 20%
Final: 30%
Paper: 25%
Section: 20%
Film Responses: 5%
Hands down one of the best professors in the AAS department. I took professor Welty for two courses and both courses taught by her were some of my favorite AAS courses taken at UCLA. She's incredibly helpful and only wants her students to succeed. She's incredibly approachable and doesn't make you feel nervous about speaking up in class and sharing your opinion. There are a lot of readings and work for the class, but the readings and pretty interesting. Highly recommend taking any of Professor Welty's class!
Professor Tamai is the sweetest, cutest, bubbliest professor ever. Her lectures are engaging and the course content is pretty interesting, especially if you are Asian American. There are weekly readings which get pretty lengthy, but you can get away with not thoroughly reading all of them, as long as you get a rough idea of what each is about. There are also a couple of film quizzes, which can get tedious but are fairly easy and often graded on completion (depending on your TA). There was no midterm, but we had a final paper (choose your own topic and given ample time to finish; also allowed for extensions). As for the final itself, it is relatively easy as long as you study the material and important concepts (an essay portion and several short response questions). She also answers questions during the exam, such as the names of important historical figures or definitions of certain course vocabulary. Participation isn't required, but I wouldn't recommend skipping, as she only posts lectures for the first ~2 weeks. Overall, I truly enjoyed this class and professor. It's an easy GE that you can get a lot out of if you take it seriously.
I really enjoyed the content of this class! My only complaint is that the TA graded the term paper kind of harshly especially considering this is a GE. This class also had a lot of readings and film responses. The final exam was a 3 hour timed essay (taken at home) and they grading was a little more lenient than the term paper.
professor tamai is really sweet and you can tell she cares a lot about what she's teaching, but i wouldn't recommend taking this class if you're not an AAS major and/or if you're not that interested in the topic.
she assigns a lot of reading each week, you can probably get by if you skim them but it's still too much imo. no midterm or exams -- just a 6-8 page term paper (but she gives you plenty of time to do it) + a final that was set up the same as the paper, but you had 2-3 days to do it instead. honestly the paper and the final were what drained me the most, since you have to do the most work for them at the same time you would need to lock in for your other classes. attendance and participation also both matter. overall, not a bad class by any means, but definitely more than i thought it would be, and she can be a bit nit-picky about the assignments.
too much work
Professor Welty is an amazing lecturer, and I would recommend anyone to take her class. She is a lot of fun, sweet, and you definitely would not regret it. She's a very clear lecturer and seriously is concerned about every one of her students and their learning. In a class of 80-ish, she also remembered quite a few names, especially if you participate. I also had a great TA, Angel, so that also contributed to the experience. The workload isn't that bad - there are a couple readings that you should do each lecture (which I honestly only skimmed or even skipped), but everything you need is gone over in detail during class anyway so you can get by not really doing most in that field. I was rather on the lazier side, but I always looked forward going to lecture even if I didn't do the reading.
Psst...the reading is from books you CAN get from the store. It's definitely on the cheaper end, and if you don't want to get the books, she uploads the parts you need onto CCLE, and there are a few copies you can check from in the library.
There's paper that is divided into a rough draft, peer review, and final draft, and you can get a lot of guidance if you want. The midterm has an essay (which prompts are discussed during discussion section) plus a few key terms, and the final has a similar format. As long as you go to each lecture and take notes, you'll be fine. Be sure to discuss the significance of each term because it is rather emphasized. Generally it's rather easy if you go to lecture.
She never posts her slides online or uses a podcast, so do yourself a favor and attend lecture each time. You might have to take quite a bit of notes (but she tells you what you need/don't need for the most part), but I can guarantee you that you'll have a great time anyway. Best GE professor so far, and it was definitely worth it!
From what I've heard about other GE's, this is definitely one of the more work-intensive ones. According to the syllabus, students are expected to read 4 hours per lecture, which in my opinion, is a lot of reading in addition to weekly reflections, tem paper, and other small homework assignments. The professor was very nice, but she was not the greatest at lecturing. The TA's were ok at best, mostly because they didn't help much, even at office hours. There were a multitude of extra credit assignments and other random assignments to pad your grade. Participation during discussions is important as well. They did not post individual grades on myUCLA, but I assume that our quarterly reflection on the grade we deserve in the class is heavily considered in assigning grades. I would do this class only if you are super passionate about Asian American studies. I did learn a lot, but there was a lot of effort needed.
Lecture:
Professor Welty uses lecture slides as a foundation for her lectures, and she comments on the slides. Her slides are not posted online, so I would recommend attending lectures. She tells you when it is unnecessary to copy down the information, such as statistics and quotes. I thoroughly enjoyed the course and found the topics interesting and relatable. Sometimes, she would show videos to illustrate her point. There will be some lectures where she would show a film and have you answer some questions and turn it in at the end of class. In general, Professor Welty is very engaging, and I looked forward to going to her lectures.
Discussion:
The discussion is made up of a short presentation by students each week and a discussion about that week's readings. I had to write six one-page reading reflection journals, which were graded very easily. Attending discussions is crucial to your grade, and you should try to engage in the discussions to earn more points. One absence = 3% marked off your grade, two absences =9% marked off your grade, three absences = 27% marked off your grade, etc.
Grade:
This is an essay GE to get an A in as long as you put in a little bit of effort. There is a midterm and a final. They both include passage identifications, which ask you to identify the key term and you will need to write about what it is and why it is important. Then, you also need to write an essay to answer one out of a few prompts. You will need to relate these to specific examples from the readings or the films. The midterm and final are both pretty easy as long as you study a little bit. There is a 6-8 page essay, and you are allowed to write about anything related to Asian American studies. Part of your grade for that is based on turning in an outline and a working draft. Discussion makes up a large portion of your grade too - this includes attendance, participation, and a group presentation. Also, there are occasional worksheets to fill out based on videos that you need to watch for homework. There are readings assigned that you are supposed to finish before each lecture, but they are really only to aid your understanding of the topic. The readings assigned are very long and sometimes boring, but Professor Welty will teach you that you only need to read the introduction, conclusion, and the first sentence of each body paragraph. You will need to buy a textbook called Contemporary Asian America, The New Chinese America, and The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. There are several opportunities to earn extra credit, such as going to a museum or attending a guest lecture. At the end of the quarter, you turn in a self-reflection to suggest what grade you think you deserve, and the TA takes it into consideration before assigning you a grade.
Grade Breakdown:
Midterm: 20%
Final: 30%
Paper: 25%
Section: 20%
Film Responses: 5%
Hands down one of the best professors in the AAS department. I took professor Welty for two courses and both courses taught by her were some of my favorite AAS courses taken at UCLA. She's incredibly helpful and only wants her students to succeed. She's incredibly approachable and doesn't make you feel nervous about speaking up in class and sharing your opinion. There are a lot of readings and work for the class, but the readings and pretty interesting. Highly recommend taking any of Professor Welty's class!
Professor Tamai is the sweetest, cutest, bubbliest professor ever. Her lectures are engaging and the course content is pretty interesting, especially if you are Asian American. There are weekly readings which get pretty lengthy, but you can get away with not thoroughly reading all of them, as long as you get a rough idea of what each is about. There are also a couple of film quizzes, which can get tedious but are fairly easy and often graded on completion (depending on your TA). There was no midterm, but we had a final paper (choose your own topic and given ample time to finish; also allowed for extensions). As for the final itself, it is relatively easy as long as you study the material and important concepts (an essay portion and several short response questions). She also answers questions during the exam, such as the names of important historical figures or definitions of certain course vocabulary. Participation isn't required, but I wouldn't recommend skipping, as she only posts lectures for the first ~2 weeks. Overall, I truly enjoyed this class and professor. It's an easy GE that you can get a lot out of if you take it seriously.
I really enjoyed the content of this class! My only complaint is that the TA graded the term paper kind of harshly especially considering this is a GE. This class also had a lot of readings and film responses. The final exam was a 3 hour timed essay (taken at home) and they grading was a little more lenient than the term paper.
professor tamai is really sweet and you can tell she cares a lot about what she's teaching, but i wouldn't recommend taking this class if you're not an AAS major and/or if you're not that interested in the topic.
she assigns a lot of reading each week, you can probably get by if you skim them but it's still too much imo. no midterm or exams -- just a 6-8 page term paper (but she gives you plenty of time to do it) + a final that was set up the same as the paper, but you had 2-3 days to do it instead. honestly the paper and the final were what drained me the most, since you have to do the most work for them at the same time you would need to lock in for your other classes. attendance and participation also both matter. overall, not a bad class by any means, but definitely more than i thought it would be, and she can be a bit nit-picky about the assignments.